Scott H Young

Restricting Yourself


Many people fail to change their habits because they focus limitations, not the opportunities that arise from those limitations. Restrictions can actually create more variety in your life.

The Paradox of Choice

The reason restrictions often add new variety is in the paradox of choice. The paradox is that, given more choices, people often make worse decisions. Cognition is a limited resource, so faced with infinite choices, people fall into the same old habits.

Keep track of the amount of different meals you eat in a month. You’ll probably be surprised to find that, even with a near infinite array of choices, you stick to the same dozen meals. Before you start any new diet, remember that you’re already restricting yourself from 99% of the meals on the planet because of a lack of imagination.

Restricting Your Eating Habits

I’m a vegetarian. I have been for over three years. The first comment I usually hear when I inform people of this is that, “I enjoy eating meat too much, I could never give it up.”

About half of the foods I cook today, I had never tried before becoming a vegetarian. In all probability, I wouldn’t have tried them if it weren’t for that decision. Becoming a vegetarian didn’t limit the variety in my foods, it simply shifted my diet to a different set of meals.

My point isn’t that everyone should become a vegetarian. Rather, don’t focus only on the limitations of a new eating pattern. Instead, use those restrictions as an opportunity to add more variety.

Restricting Your Time

I first discovered Toastmasters when I was on a self-imposed restriction to avoid television. By avoiding one use of time, my opportunities expanded to allow me to enjoy completely new hobbies.

I had a similar experience when restricting my computer usage. Suddenly I was reading more books because I broke my old habits.

Restrictions aren’t a limitation of your choices, but a shift in those choices. Now, instead of examining one set of activities or behaviors, you have a completely new set. Creative leaps come from constraints.

Getting Out of Your Default

When I discuss giving up meat, waking up early or eliminating television some people get wide-eyed with fear and disgust. It’s as if I told them I spend several hours a day with a flail mutilating myself out of piety.

What’s harder to explain is that most of my efforts towards restriction are for the exact opposite goal. Utilizing restrictions to get myself to do more interesting things. Giving up internet usage isn’t to limit my life, but the opposite, to enjoy it more. By restricting one set of choices, I can get out of my default behaviors and make more interesting choices.

There is this myth that people are perfectly rational, and that they will always pick the utility maximizing choice, when they have the option. That’s garbage. People are irrational, and that includes me. Given the choice, people do what they did yesterday, not what’s best.

Restriction Takes Effort

Adding new limitations to your routine does take some effort to adjust to. People are habitual creatures, so it takes more brainpower to divert your resources. Like changing the direction of a river, it can take some effort to break out of your current path.

I’ve already written extensively about how to change habits, but the advice is rather simple. Focus on one change per month, and be ruthlessly consistent. If you can do this, after a few weeks, the new behavior should be automatic.

Experimental Restrictions

My policy is that no restriction on my life is ever permanent. I’m a vegetarian today. A year from now I may be eating meat. I expect absolutely no permanence in my life on a fundamental level. Everything is simply another iteration as I’m constantly trying to improve.

My goal for restrictions is to make them habits. Once they are habits, then I no longer need to force myself to pursue them. From the standpoint of a habit, I can neutrally evaluate whether they are worthwhile to maintain. Some I keep because I like them, others I discard.

The goal of using restrictions is to expose yourself to a wider variety of experiences. I don’t consider it a failure if I let an old habit slip when the context changes. My purpose was satisfied, and providing I made the decision consciously, it was still successful.

As of this moment, I’m waking up at 7:30 am, and not 5:30, as I had been in the past. Early rising is a great habit, but given my current schedule it isn’t useful. I’ll probably take it up again later, but I don’t consider it a personal failure if I make a switch. If you make every constraint an experiment, you are always in control.

Escaping the Ordinary

There is always a balance. New restrictions create new opportunities. If you pursue your goals in that light, it isn’t as hard to summon the willpower to make a change. You may realize when you’re done that the restrictions weren’t so difficult, and they gave you the ability to try something new.


Print Friendly
StumbleUpon It!

This website is supported, in part, by affiliate arrangements (usually Amazon). Affiliate relationships are always marked by bolded links.


11 Responses to “Restricting Yourself”

  1. Spesh says:

    What if, instead of creating new restrictions on yourself, you just signed-up/committed to new activities? Then that new activity would keep you busy during time that you may have used for an old activity/habit?

    The sentence, “Given the choice, people do what they did yesterday, not what’s best.”, is exactly true in my experience. That is a concise way to state that phenomenon and I hope to think of that sentence the next time I go to prove how true it is.

  2. Enrique S says:

    You’re so right. People prefer to stay in their comfort zones. Old habits die hard. I’m in the process of giving up coffee. I call it a process, because I’m still reluctant to quit it entirely. But I found that rather than slow me down in the morning, I’m actually getting to work earlier, and my productivity hasn’t suffered. Most of the time, we’re our own impediment to success.

  3. Asia Hadley says:

    A great book to read is the Paradox of Choice by Barry Schwartz. You’ll enjoy it. I saw him do a speech on TED talking about how people can be less happy when presented with too many choices.

  4. Scott Young says:

    Spesh,

    I’ve actually written about this before, you can do a search in the sidebar for “maximizers” and “simplifiers”. About two different strategies for creating a more interesting, productive life.

    -Scott

  5. Helen Lewis says:

    Intuitively this makes so much sense – restrictions force some creative response from the brain to find a way around it. Artists, musicians, architects all work within a set of restrictions.

    I think the link between creativity and restrictions is why people often leave assignments to the last minute. I found I could never start writing an essay until about 1 am of the day it was due in. The pressure of time often forces the best ideas to the front of the mind.

    Unfortunately for my grades, this approach only produced quality essays when I had had plenty of time to read and think about the topic beforehand. The mind has to chew things over, digest, and sometimes spit things out.

    I’m a Toastmaster too, and I find that my best speeches are those that have been rehearsed about a week before the event and then gone through a small but significant last-minute revision.

    If there are any other Toastmasters reading this, I’d like to know how you prepare for speeches.

  6. Vlad Dolezal says:

    “There is this myth that people are perfectly rational, and that they will always pick the utility maximizing choice, when they have the option. That’s garbage. People are irrational, and that includes me. Given the choice, people do what they did yesterday, not what’s best.” – Scott H. Young

    That’s going on my list of favorite quotes :)

    When I first switched to eating vegetarian, I simply substituted non-meat alternatives for the meat foods. I used to eat. Then I realized how ridiculous that is… eating vegetarian sausages and burgers? Come on :)

    After that, I expanded my horizons and realized that eating vegetarian isn’t just a restricted subset of eating meat foods. It’s honestly DIFFERENT. Just like you say, Scott. I noticed new choices I never would have explored otherwise.

  7. David Cain says:

    Great concept, I’ll have to experiment with it.

    I’m not a vegetarian but I have stopped buying meat. It was expensive and not particularly healthy. I use extra-firm tofu for everything, and ended up inventing all kinds of dishes that would never have existed without that restriction.

    A lot of possibilities here.

  8. Steve says:

    This is a great way to look at change. Often, we are ambivalent about change because we don’t want to ‘give something up’ We fail to see that we are giving up something not so great, for something really great. Now, it’s time for me to figure out what I am going to restrict…

  9. […] that I had the data, I realized how much I’m glued to the computer. So I started restricting myself on weekends to spend less time in front of the computer and more time doing other […]

  10. […] restrict time in front of the computer on weekends and outside work hours […]

  11. […] that I had the data, I realized how much I’m glued to the computer. So I started restricting myself on weekends to spend less time in front of the computer and more time doing other […]

Debate is fine, flaming is not. Pretend that this comment form is a discussion taking place in my house. That means I enjoy constructive criticism and polite suggestions. Personal attacks, insults and all-purpose nastiness will be removed especially if it is directed at other readers.

Leave a Reply